SafetyPinndSally
August 16, 2006 - 07:05 PM
Are the judges on crack?!
I'm sorry, but I'd rather look like a pudgy, yellow mouse, than look like some tubular waist-paper basket, thank you very much.
Sure Allison was off point with her design, but she has clearly been on-point with all of her previous ones. Uh, hello?! Remember Vincent's very first outfit?! Yeah...that was a brilliant idea of his...if we were all on crack.
Vincent isn't even that funny. I'd rather watch Kayne and Laura go at it than watch him try to make some cracked-out dress. More entertainment for me.
ACK! Right now I'm so very tempted to stop watching this effing show because they refuse to throw of that [censored] melon of a man.
Collpepper
August 16, 2006 - 07:05 PM
QUOTE
Hey- just because she's bigger then the other models doesn't mean she's fat.
I'm not thrilled with the fat comments Heidi made...I seem to remember a little number she wore while she was pregnant that I thought was just horrendous on her. It had poufs everywhere, and IT was made with real material...not trash...how would she have felt if someone said she looked fat?
ontherange
August 16, 2006 - 07:06 PM
Totally agree with the out, Alison's was much uglier than Vincents and had much less of a point of view.
Disagree with the winner. Jeff's was far and away the best looking.
Laura is really being a [expletive deleted] just for the sake of being a [expletive deleted], or at least no apparent provocation as edited together.
superkay
August 16, 2006 - 07:06 PM
Quote:
Me too. ALL of these designs looked like garbage, really. ): WTF, Jeffery. Diabetic foods?
I think Jeffrey is starting to get just a little bit bitter that he hasn't won a challenge yet. One minute i like him cause he's actually laughing and then he opens his mouth and he spews .
Can't wait till next week, the Everday Woman?? Who was that shadow??
EllieMicelli
August 16, 2006 - 07:06 PM
I'm on the left coast too. Sounds like Vincent is getting by each week despite consistently below average offerings. Haven't seen his work tonight, but last week's Very Brady Twiggy dress was, eck. Someone please, tell me Alison's was worse than his tonight...because I just can't imagine it.
KSboy
August 16, 2006 - 07:06 PM
Quote:
I think the point is that she's not plus size. Even plus size models don't want clothing that makes them look heavier.
I agree. I don't think Allison lost because she made a plus-size dress. I think she lost because she made a dress that was not attractive for her model's build. I'm very thin, and I'm smart enough to know that fashions that look good on more muscular men don't look good on me. The same goes with thinner or heavier women. A good designer should know how to design for his client's personal build. Allison, unfortunately, failed at that.
damselfly
August 16, 2006 - 07:06 PM
How can they choose to take Kayne's past work into consideration but not Vincent's and Allison's if they did that would have gone diferently
MissOtis
August 16, 2006 - 07:07 PM
Laura is SUCH A [expletive deleted]!!!
nycitymom
August 16, 2006 - 07:07 PM
THIS SHOW IS ALL ABOUT CHARACTERS TO KEEP US INTERESTED - NOT FASHION!!!!! THE FACT THAT KAYNE AND VINCENT WAS JUDGED ON THEIR POTENTIAL PAST AND FUTURE AS OPPOSED TO ALLISON KELLY WHO WAS VOTED JUST ON THIS PARTICULAR CHALLENGE, IS BY FAR THE MOST UNFAIR JUDGING THAT HAS CAME ABOUT. IT WAS CRYSTAL CLEAR THAT KAYNE SHOULD HAVE BEEN OUT TONIGHT.
longhorn
August 16, 2006 - 07:07 PM
i cant believe they kicked off alison...that makes me mad!
Jadis
August 16, 2006 - 07:07 PM
Vincent is one big joke, throwing a bunch of garbage onto a flat white canvas should not get you into the next round! Allison didn't deserve to go yet, while everyone has to go sometime she deserved to stay longer than some wack job, would anyone honestly buy clothes from Vincent after seeing him on this show, and not to mention that most of his garments are crap.
oscarsimon
August 16, 2006 - 07:07 PM
I liked Vincent's idea - - it did look like a piece of art. Sorry - but he far surpased Allison's outfit.
SUKI_267
August 16, 2006 - 07:07 PM
project runway has lost one viewer! I absolutely love this show and live for fashion, but voting allison off was the stupidest decision EVER!!! She is the best, most up to date, designer in the whole cast, she was supposed to win! She is obviously more than 100 times better than vincent and everyone else there in fact! Is it her fault her model is fat, I think not! Project Runway needs to get there stuff straight, if they REALLY are lookin for the top desinger in america they totally blew it this time around!
damselfly
August 16, 2006 - 07:08 PM
Quote:
Quote:
Hey- just because she's bigger then the other models doesn't mean she's fat.
I'm not thrilled with the fat comments Heidi made...I seem to remember a little number she wore while she was pregnant that I thought was just horrendous on her. It had poufs everywhere, and IT was made with real material...not trash...how would she have felt if someone said she looked fat?
While she was pregnant...How about the blue drapey thing at the top of this episode...
spiritisb
August 16, 2006 - 07:09 PM
Boo! Boo on Project Runway. Last Week Tim said that Parson's and Project Runway were nothing without their integrity and in my book you just lost it all. You've done crappy things in the past but this takes it. Shame on you. I am seriously considering whether I will watch at all anymore.
bthlyann
August 16, 2006 - 07:09 PM
i sooo agree with you. i am sorry vincent sucks. he should have been off on the first episode. he is terrible, has terrible taste and his stuff looks like junk. kayne can make a good dress...but so can alison! so why didnt they take that into consideration. i am sorry, project runway is starting to piss me off. i feel like they are only keeping on the psycho freaks just for ratings and to keep it interesting with the drama. isnt this show supposed to be about the CLOTHES AND THE DESIGNER????? NOT ABOUT THE DRAMA!!!!!
Spoiled
August 16, 2006 - 07:09 PM
I am not the only one who thought that was a horrible statement I see. "you made her look like a Plus size Model! I mean she made it see like Allsion made her look like a Gorilla or something. I mean she made it seem like the worst thing in the world is being a Plus Size Model.... Whatever... That was a low Blow.../.Any Who!!!!
Michael Rocks@@@ I love him He really rocks!!!!
Vincent should have left and not Alison!!!
courtesi
August 16, 2006 - 07:09 PM
I started watching Bravo TV when Top Chef aired and although I meant to register before, I never got around to it. After tonight - I had to share my opinion.
JEFFREY WAS ROBBED.
That's all I have to say...
harajuku
August 16, 2006 - 07:10 PM
The loser was a producers decision. I've never even been to these boards before, but I created a user name just to say that it couldn't be any clearer. Vincent has been in the bottem 3 how many times? Common, they want him in because he's "good television". I love this show, but that decision insults our intelligence.
fooey
August 16, 2006 - 07:10 PM
Vincent is useless. That was a bunch of BS. Makes me want to stop watching the show all together. Allison was robbed.
Oh it's so "arty." Anyone who calls art "arty" has no concept of actual art.
lisakaz
August 16, 2006 - 07:10 PM
Quote:
You know Jeffery never has anything good to say about anyone else. I didn't think his fashion was bad tonight, but it did not wow me either.
I would have much preferred Vincent go home and Allison stay. She has a sense of style and has done some beautiful things on the show. Vincent has done some kind of screwy carp every week.
Thank god Robert did a good dress and was not in the bottom again.
Katyne is very lucky that he has done some great things before because he blew this thing tonight.
Laura did a nice little plain dress.
Angela did something that would have been perfect for Bradley last week, I can so see Cher in that lol.
I didn't even notice what Uli did, will have to watch again.
I hated Angela's AGAIN. I guess there were bigger fish to fry but her taste level imo was worse than Kayne's. She's got this [expletive deleted] aesthetic I guess and I think it's really bad taste.
floss
August 16, 2006 - 07:10 PM
Quote:
I believe Alison made a good dress, seeing she had to work with TRASH!
As they all did.
oscarsimon
August 16, 2006 - 07:11 PM
Yeah - well they may have lost this viewer too - - - "pick the simplest elegant dress" - - and you have a winner - everytime.
Look - - I am 60 years old - - - and I am bored with their decisions.
Isn't this supposed to be a show on new innovative and creative designers??? BORING - BORING - BORING - BORING.
Maybe they need a dictionary to explain to them what creative and innovative is.
Vexelle
August 16, 2006 - 07:11 PM
Not really. I think Vincent and Allison, construction-wise, looked a LOT worse than Kayne. ):
uhohwhoopsbroken
August 16, 2006 - 07:12 PM
You know I think I'd like to see what the judges would come up with for designs on some of these challenges. Some of Heidi's recent outfits look like they too came from a New Jersey recycling center. At least this week she restrained herself from making the comment "it looks cheap". Poo on their choice to off Allison, at least her previous designs were lovely. I too enjoy Vincent's insanity, but it shouldn't be the only reason he remains.
reachmeatlauren
August 16, 2006 - 07:13 PM
agreed!!!!!! I have never wanted to reach through my TV and punch Heidi Klume so badly! And what is wrong with plus size models? We aren't all size 2 nor would I want to be. And that [censored] is one to talk ever since she had that kid she wears the most unflattering dumpy looking [censored]. [censored] her, [censored] her up her stupid asses. [censored]!
trixxi
August 16, 2006 - 07:13 PM
Are you kidding me?? Getting rid of Allison over Vincent is the biggest mistake I have ever seen on this show.
He is horrible!! Are they keeping him for the drama!!
oscarsimon
August 16, 2006 - 07:13 PM
Yes - I liked Kaynes original design - - - Tim is not always right.
superkay
August 16, 2006 - 07:13 PM
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Hey- just because she's bigger then the other models doesn't mean she's fat.
I'm not thrilled with the fat comments Heidi made...I seem to remember a little number she wore while she was pregnant that I thought was just horrendous on her. It had poufs everywhere, and IT was made with real material...not trash...how would she have felt if someone said she looked fat?
While she was pregnant...How about the blue drapey thing at the top of this episode...
That blue glam granny goth see through outfit? And she's one of the judges!! She's one of the most beautiful women in the world and she dresses worse than my 9 year old niece. But if it has a hefty price tag, maybe that makes it okay, because of course if it costs alot it MUST be fashionable!
thadgarrison
August 16, 2006 - 07:13 PM
What a load of horseshit! This show is blatantly making decisions in order to manufacture a false drama. Allison did absolutely nothing wrong up to this point, though her outfit was awful. Vincent, on the other hand, made yet another piece of garbage and was allowed to pass on. The girl couldn't even walk in it! What a joke.
Honestly, this kind of nonsense makes me seriously consider not watching the show any longer. I watch it for the talent, not for the faux drama. I can get faux drama on 1,000 other reality shows.
Wake up, your audience isn't stupid!
LisaM
August 16, 2006 - 07:13 PM
As an avid Project Runway viewer since Season 1, I haven't always agreed with the judges' decisions, but at least they were always able to rationalize their choices in a sane, reasonable way.
Project Runway in Season 3 has jumped the shark. Once the most innovative and (dare I say) honest "reality" shows on tv, this season it is every bit as staged, unrealistic and tabloidy as every other reality program on the air. The fact that the judges decided to eliminate a proven talent to save the producers' obvious favorite only emphasizes my point. (Seriously, are the ratings not high enough? Let's not get greedy people.)
"Project Runway is nothing without its integrity." Maybe in Season 1 and Season 2. But I'm afraid to say, Tim, Project Runway just isn't making it work anymore.
Jazzie53
August 16, 2006 - 07:13 PM
Quote:
I am not the only one who thought that was a horrible statement I see. "you made her look like a Plus size Model! I mean she made it see like Allsion made her look like a Gorilla or something. I mean she made it seem like the worst thing in the world is being a Plus Size Model.... Whatever... That was a low Blow.../.Any Who!!!!
Michael Rocks@@@ I love him He really rocks!!!!
Vincent should have left and not Alison!!!
Not only was it a low blow....in its own way, a slam on all of us plus size women who watch the show! I know it's already filmed and so on and so on.....but Bravo...TAKE NOTE!
Jazzie
PS: and would those of you who have bought into the "plus size" comment as being the model is fat, please rethink your statement. My fat little self might take it personal, doncha know! *smile*
KSboy
August 16, 2006 - 07:15 PM
Quote:
Laura is SUCH A [expletive deleted]!!!
Laura and Vincent are such pricks. Kayne was absolutely right. The end should have focused on honoring Allison and wishing her goodbye -- not a fight between Ms. Prim-and-Proper and Mr. Nutcase.
Kayne and Allison were two of the most talented designers this season (along with Michael and maybe Uli and Robert). Unfortunately, they both had off nights tonight. As much as I don't care for Vincent, and didn't like his dress once again, I would have made the bottom two Kayne and Allison.
Carole
August 16, 2006 - 07:15 PM
Quote:
you know what though, i also like kayne mostly and so i'm kinda sad that they don't like each other. of course he has that annoying thing everyone from the south has which is that when they come up north they have to tell everyone they meet that they're from the south for some strange reason. it gets old really fast.
I think they really do like each other and just scratch at each other for fun. We say we are from the South because how else would you explain how we talk?
Marilyn042
August 16, 2006 - 07:15 PM
Jeff is a total arrogant jerk, but he TOTALLY deserved to win!! That dress was gorgeous, very innovative and loaded with personality. Michael's was good (and he's a total sweetheart), but it didn't have the punch that Jeff's did.
LayB
August 16, 2006 - 07:15 PM
I agree. I'm sorry but I'd rather look "big" and cute than skinny and hideous. Vincent's outfit didn't even look like anything close to an actual dress. And I'm sorry, but Alison's was far more creative. Vincent just made a basic, very basic, stiff dress and threw a bunch of stuff on...he even said it himself. I also believe this might have been a producers decision or Heidi's. I also did not appreciate her comment about "Would you rather look big or long and slender?" Excuse me, the world is not about being skinny. And her model did not like as gargantuan as Heidi would have had you believe by her words and tone. VIncent has NEVER sent anything the judges truly liked or gave praise to down the runway. Alison actually has. I am very disappointed once again this season at who has been kicked off.
13ounces
August 16, 2006 - 07:15 PM
I'm glad most are angry like me. How many times do you have to be in the bottom 2 or 3 to leave. Didn't they say something like 'you've been in the bottom too many times' in the past!?! Hasn't Vincent been in it almost everytime?! God, what a moron. I can't beleive Alison left. The judges need to get their heads out of their arses! What a JOKE... And I agree, Jeffrey was ROBBED!
GDiddy
August 16, 2006 - 07:15 PM
That was a HORRIBLE Decision by the judges, It was Allisons first Outfit that wasnt so Hot ANd Vincent Just Sucks. His Outfit was 10 Times worse than hers and he puts out crap almost every time. This was a BS decision This show is Rigged BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!1!!!
floss
August 16, 2006 - 07:15 PM
Quote:
I hated Angela's AGAIN. I guess there were bigger fish to fry but her taste level imo was worse than Kayne's. She's got this [expletive deleted] aesthetic I guess and I think it's really bad taste.
Agreed. Angela's garment looked like a sluttly maxi pad.
PJMNYC2006
August 16, 2006 - 07:16 PM
I agree. She was robbed. She has consistantly been in the top or pass group where Vincent has almost as consitently been on the bottom and skated through. Kayne made the worst dress of the night and it looked bloody awful but they didn't want to bag the actual loser because that would have gotten rid of a character (and I like the guy, so it is not about him) but they boot a good designer for a proven failure (Vincent). The fact that he is still on the show tells me something just doesn't add up. Knight's piece was not the best, Jeff's was by the account of everyone in my house, but they are both good.
Either there is too much producer interference or not enough. It should be planned to get rid of designers based at least in some part on their talent levels and that is not happening and it is WAY too obvious. If it goes by worst per challenge, Kayne should have gone homs. If it goes by worst performer - generally - Vincent should have gone home. If it is some split between the two, Vincet should still have gone home. The decisions seems far too arbitrary on tonight's show. I really think that I am done watching it because I don't buy it any more.
damselfly
August 16, 2006 - 07:16 PM
Quote:
Vincent is useless. That was a bunch of BS. Makes me want to stop watching the show all together. Allison was robbed.
Oh it's so "arty." Anyone who calls art "arty" has no concept of actual art.
Amen...he should have been thrown off for that comment right then...What a wack job, why would anyone want his "pieces" associated with a show that has Micheal Kohrs and the fashion editor of Elle on it telling us that that is fashionable. Every designer on there so far has had 1 design that could sell in the right market...except Vincent...
velouria75
August 16, 2006 - 07:16 PM
Vincent has to **ucking GO!!! I realize that I'm just some uneducated nobody and maybe it's a high art thing and some plebe like me just doesn't get it but I am getting fed up with this Vincent free ride bulls*it. The judges are over compensating for him and "understanding" him too much. His stuff has been unwearable boring ill fitting crap. I can't believe little Allison went. Her dress was awful, esp on her "zaftig" model. I love the fashion industry, the only place where some size 8 model is considered obese. I did wish, Allison that you had used the striped skirt you made and just made it into much smaller panels connected by little o rings or something, like a kilt. I loved Uli's dress the best-- it looked like brocade! Michael classy as always and I was glad to see Robert rebound. I like Jeffery's clothes but that macho, elitest crap he's contantly spewing makes me dislike him and enjoy the fact that he's never won a challenge. I guess that talent & intelligence don't always add up to social aplomb. Jeffery's the poster child for gagging on ones own foot. Anyway, good tv, I'll be tuning in next week fer shur...
dajamg
August 16, 2006 - 07:16 PM
I'm so upset that Alison's gone... was anyone else just waiting for her and Jeffrey to get together? I'll admit he's an ass, but I like him anyway, and he looked really affectionate towards her.
and Angela needs to go, completely agree that she has no taste whatsoever. ditto Vincent.
Sher
August 16, 2006 - 07:16 PM
Quote:
agreed!!!!!! I have never wanted to reach through my TV and punch Heidi Klume so badly! And what is wrong with plus size models? We aren't all size 2 nor would I want to be. And that [censored] is one to talk ever since she had that kid she wears the most unflattering dumpy looking [censored]. [censored] her, [censored] her up her stupid asses. [censored]!
Sweetie, you have to quit candy coating and tell us how you REALLY feel.
Allison got sucked into Angela's bubbleskirt fetish, apparently.
fooey
August 16, 2006 - 07:17 PM
The more I think about it the more mad I get. Vincent does not deserve to be on the show and his "dress" was by FAR the worst tonight. I'm so SICK of his "Kooky" designs. Tonight was a joke. I think my favorite show just jumped the shark.
FastFck
August 16, 2006 - 07:17 PM
Im with u! Vincent is the WORST! he should go back to 1986 where he belongs!
krash
August 16, 2006 - 07:17 PM
Quote:
Are you kidding me?? Getting rid of Allison over Vincent is the biggest mistake I have ever seen on this show.
He is horrible!! Are they keeping him for the drama!!
if that was meant to be posed as a question, the answer is a resounding YES. clearly, this was a producer induced choice and we all know they have a pretty big say but this was so naked and blatent that its pissing people off. of course ratings are important but they need to do it with a bit more care. this was just too much. obviously.
britneeee
August 16, 2006 - 07:17 PM
I can honestly say right now i have no idea why Jefferey didnt win. Micheals design was alright, good enough to qualify him to move on, but it was nothing compared to Jeffereys. Even the judges said his was the only one that actually MOVED with the model. I thought the plastic on Micheals outfit was bulky. Angelas dress was completely, dare i say, GAWDY. It was terrible. Her and Vincent should have both been kicked off by now. Actually i dont see how Vincent wasnt kicked off in the very first challenge.
MissOtis
August 16, 2006 - 07:18 PM
I absolutely hate to see Alison go. She is SO talented. She has made some wonderful and very interesting outfits. I think they made their decision tonight on fit and hers did not fit.
Although I don't think it is possible for me to think more of Michael than I do and I loved his dress tonight, I would have liked to have seen Jeff win. I loved his colors.
Somebody please help me. I am beginning to like Vincent.
bthlyann
August 16, 2006 - 07:18 PM
this is all complete [censored]. i never thought i could be mad at project runway. this show consumes my life and i never thought i could really consider not watching it. absolute [censored].
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please
click here.