Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Episode 314: FINALE, PART TWO!
BravoTV Message Boards > Shows > Project Runway > Project Runway - Season 3
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31
tamarinden
Quote:

Quote:

brillke, you have over 1k posts

what do you have to say about yourself





I say, boy are my fingers getting tired.

brillke




1000 posts ! And we love all of them
Spearshaker75
Quote:

Quote:

Well, I guess if "cutting edge" these days means creating garments that didn't even flatter young, anoerexic size 0 fashion models let alone an average body-type buyer, then I will be just as happy to remain a conservative old fuddy-duddy! I just really wish the fashion industry would give a little more consideration to average-to-plus size folk who are older than twenty-something. I mean really... what are we to do... be doomed to being considered "unfashinable" for the rest of our lives?




Women have complained about that stuff for YEARS! Would you like to revisit the days of corsets? or maybe tiny shoes/wraps so our feet won't grow like the asian people? We could talk about the women who start as young girls wrapping metal around their necks to press down the shoulders and muscles to give the illusion of length - only seeing their real neck when their necklaces are changed as they grow. Fashion isn't about fair to all anywhere in the world. Do you think shoe models have size 11 feet? No, they are usually around a size 5.5 or 6. Hand models having large and muscular fingers noway! Dainty and thin with nice nails is how they are chosen.

My point? Nothing is going to change the "twiggy" image in fashion shows. Emme was the only thing that got plus-sized models in the public eye. Maybe there was a show for such models? Unfortunately that isn't what sells. Thin, beautiful girls are what sells. It's all about sales, money, marketing. It's only about real women when it comes to cup size! and have those are fake!

Really tho, those fashion shows are not really about the everyday woman. They are about who is going to design the clothes. We are not going to wear metallic gold tights with foil breast plates/shirts...... check those out in the Paris shows!!! It's just about their getting attention and then editing those designs and ideas in various ways including materials.

That's what I Think everyone is missing that doesn't get it. I personally wouldn't wear anything Jeffrey designed cause it wouldn't look good on me as a 43 y/o woman. I'm not who he is designing for, nor am I who PR is wanting to see designs for. They want to see versatility within the guidelines of what's considered beautiful in models. Young, skinny, different. Look at the models themselves in the past 10 to 20 years. They've changed races, facial ideas of beauty, but they are still young and skinny.

I'm an old fuddy duddy and if I had reason to purchase something from any of those designers it would probably come from Laura. If I were a free-spirited young girl again, I'd be all over Jeffrey's clothing. That doesn't mean every girl would be either.

There are arguments for both sides because no way is definitely the right way - because it's all about taste. HOWEVER, as I have said before - PR asked for new, innovative, versitile designers. Jeffrey proved he could be that - like everyone else he also made some mistakes. He just lucked out on the runway.

I thought Kaynes coutour gown was pretty. YES, it was a bit much, but the idea was really cute. Those people thought it was gross. Oh well......




GREAT GREAT post! Are Bianca Jagger or Liza Minelli still wearing their original Halstons? Fashion isn't about fairness all the time because sometimes, at least, it's also ostensibly about art, and art is sometimes about things it takes an effort to appreciate. I read these arguments and sometimes it makes me think of the same reasons why certain people read books or see movies. Some will say, I read Shakespeare or James Joyce because they want to be engaged, challenged, and forced out of themselves; while others disdain such a pursuit, and say, "The hell with that. I read Danielle Steele or James Paterson because I want to pass the time and be entertained, and that's why I like Bruce Willis too!" This season in a way tried to replicate that divide - there was an "everyday woman" challenge along with a "couture" challenge: both of these in a sense represent the polar opposites of why designers design. The point being - if you look at a painting or read a novel and judge it solely upon whether it's according to your taste, as opposed to its truly artistic merits (a lot of people don't find Shakespeare to their taste; but would they truly want to debate the merits of Shakespeare as opposed to, say, JK Rowling?), then you're not getting a full picture; just as if you look at a fashion collection and say, "Why should I like these clothes? Neither I nor anyone I know could ever wear them"! Most of the time with such opinions we say a lot more about ourselves than the product we presume to be critiquing.
Spearshaker75
Quote:

Quote:

Bottom line:

Michael designs clothes for [expletive deleted].

Jeffrey designs clothes for crack [expletive deleted]. He's also hostile to women despite his "romantic" crap. He wanted to "make the models go away" and use wigs to disguise them all.

Interesting how both the men designed clothes for how they want to see women. Both women designed clothes they'd want to wear.

It's unimaginable that Uli didn't win and that Laura didn't win. If one collection was "$30,000" and a judge would "wear every one of them" for the other, then we've all been had. They're judging in a way that we're not privy to. And this show has jumped the shark.




Laura's designs showed just as much skin, though veiled by see through fabric, than either of the men. What do you have to say about that?




First of all, c'mon - anyone who wears more than a loin cloth knows the diff between exposing bare skin and wearing a beaded, worked over bustier! You're being a bit sophistic with thius argument in saying the "showing skin' is showing skin...period...it doesn't matter HOW it's shown. Sort of like removing a quote from its context to serve a partisan purpose.

But I'll stick to the topic. To me, Michael's idea of sexiness seems to be gratuitous skin. A strip of fabric here, a bunched ruching there, and that's an outfit to him. Is that hip-hop? I really do feel compelled at this point to get some clarification on what exactly hip-hop fashion is. When he designed that wonderful white Jet-Set piece, Michael was hailed as a hip-hop designer; now, because he presents slightly refined stripper-wear on the runway, there's some kind of anti-hip-hop conspiracy? So is hip-hop fashion what Diddy wears in the Hamptons, or is it the pasties Lil Kim wears to the Grammys? I'm just asking; and hopefully Michael will someday soon make a decision, and someone with his vision (which is unquestionable) will have the answer for those of us who are still confused; clearly, though, Michael is still confused, and if THAT is a look he's trying to deal with and help to define, he has some work to do.

I thought Jeffery would win from the beginning. Did I like his collection the best? No. Uli's was far superior to me. The comment that Kors made about Jeffery that he thought of every moment of his woman's life could just as easily have been said about Uli. And Jeffery had more near-misses in my opinion than Uli. As for Laura, good god! except for a couple of gowns, I thought I was watching a funeral procession. No matter how exquisitely made or subtly different, black dress after black dress coming down a runway is just tricky.
brillke
Just read this in the EW interview with Tim Gunn.

"Any other behind-the-scenes scoop that we didn't see on TV?

Vincent, my heartthrob — no, I'm teasing. If I were to say that with seriousness, put a bullet in my head. What you didn't see is when we were taping the reunion show, after that clip with Vincent, Michael Rucker, the producer who was in the scene with him doing all the screaming and yelling, came out to present him with a whole stack of new shirts, which was really lovely. And as soon as we broke for commercial, Vincent stood up and walked them to a garbage can and dumped them. He's crazy."



Wow,speaks volumes about the guy, huh? He was so gracious about them on the reunion show. He seemed very pleased yet he turns around and does this?

brillke
tamarinden
Quote:

Just read this in the EW interview with Tim Gunn.

"Any other behind-the-scenes scoop that we didn't see on TV?

Vincent, my heartthrob — no, I'm teasing. If I were to say that with seriousness, put a bullet in my head. What you didn't see is when we were taping the reunion show, after that clip with Vincent, Michael Rucker, the producer who was in the scene with him doing all the screaming and yelling, came out to present him with a whole stack of new shirts, which was really lovely. And as soon as we broke for commercial, Vincent stood up and walked them to a garbage can and dumped them. He's crazy."



Wow,speaks volumes about the guy, huh? He was so gracious about them on the reunion show. He seemed very pleased yet he turns around and does this?

brillke






I saw this side of Vincent in the way he treated Angela. I sized that up and when people were saying "Oh Vincent is so sweet" I just never saw that.

He seemed very very vicious with her when she stood up to him. I am not saying that Angela was perfect, but it was Vincent's fault as he was constantly rolling his eyes at her and smirking and saying "I'm team leadah"!

Angela never really was given the benefit of the doubt by certain designers after she repudiated Vincent on the runway and said she did not like his design. Her problem is that she doesnt know how to play interpersonal politics very well. But she was clearly sabotaged by Vincent and right after Uli said she didnt want to room with Angela.

I suppose it must have been devine retribution for Angela to see how Vincent's insanity and disgusting behavior on display for all to see during the reunion show.
mainer
Quote:

Lovely post ty I enjoyed this and loved the collections.

And I am glad Laura did it her way. Frankly, seeing the horrendous negativity directed toward Jeffrey since he won, I am glad Laura or Uli didnt win. it would have been too painful hearing the kind of attacks on them that have been directed toward Jeffrey. I am emotionally involved in their collections so it would have affected me worse.

Of course we have had to endure some pretty harsh attacks on Laura anyway, but NOTHING like what would have happened had she won. Same for Uli.

I have been touched by Uli since her collection. I see now what she is about, and her sense of beauty, her drive, they affected my life, as of course have Laura's. Is there anything more beautiful that one can say about the work of an artist than to say that their work has touched you deeply?


I think this is the highest compliment one can give an artist. I was just thinking the same thing about Laura or Uli winning. You can bet this board would have gone just as nuts if one of them had won. I am still conflicted about how I feel about Bravo. They're gay-friendly yet choose to show straight guys spouting misogynistic crap. Go figure. I have loved fashion since I was a teenager; and I have always loved art and design, but I'm having a hard time even liking Bravo.
AI




beautiful post AI n very thoughtful. i agree with you all the way. the nastiness that would have happened would have been off the wall. i do think both uli n laura will go farther then jeffery in the world of fashion for real women.

alice
mainer
Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

Lovely post ty I enjoyed this and loved the collections.

And I am glad Laura did it her way. Frankly, seeing the horrendous negativity directed toward Jeffrey since he won, I am glad Laura or Uli didnt win. it would have been too painful hearing the kind of attacks on them that have been directed toward Jeffrey. I am emotionally involved in their collections so it would have affected me worse.

Of course we have had to endure some pretty harsh attacks on Laura anyway, but NOTHING like what would have happened had she won. Same for Uli.

I have been touched by Uli since her collection. I see now what she is about, and her sense of beauty, her drive, they affected my life, as of course have Laura's. Is there anything more beautiful that one can say about the work of an artist than to say that their work has touched you deeply?


I think this is the highest compliment one can give an artist. I was just thinking the same thing about Laura or Uli winning. You can bet this board would have gone just as nuts if one of them had won. I am still conflicted about how I feel about Bravo. They're gay-friendly yet choose to show straight guys spouting misogynistic crap. Go figure. I have loved fashion since I was a teenager; and I have always loved art and design, but I'm having a hard time even liking Bravo.
AI




What? I mean, really, what's the f**k? Like I've never heard a woman spout the same sort of drivel about men? I am really having a hard time with you all today and I now know why I'm so happy being gay.

I also now know why I'm one of the few men posting at this board, but no longer.

Damn I'm glad this was the last show. Hasta So Longa!



Sorry you're having a hard time today, Bear. Of course women spout the same kind of drivel. Please don't put words in people's mouths. What the f**k is wrong with you today? I'm not allowed to have an opinion? Yeah, I have a problem with some of Jeffrey's language, so what?
AI




amen AI me too......... guess what simple there are other adjectives you can use ........ n we all have our right to our opinion. this is a TV show get a grip. its not real life in any stretch of the word.

alice
mainer
Quote:

"GOD YOU GUYS ARE ALL SUCH BABIES."

"And those of you who claim to never watch thye show again, well you are worse then any of them. Grow up. Or not, because personally, I don't think Bravo really cares if you small group of children don't tune in anymore."


You say this, then this,

"Everyone just needs to get off their high horses, quit personally attacking a man you do not know anything about other than the edited clips you've seen on tv, and jus tget over it."


Hello kettle, you visit here so often.

brillke








its a tv show n as much as i have had my ques about the judging like any good addictive person i will be back next season to most likly gripe so more lol. personally dont care about their personal life as some might not like mine . they didnt come to win a personality contest they came to design of not design. lol
liked some n didnt loke some n thats my right as a person that pays her electric bill ( no one else does so i can type what i please). if people cont like what i think they can pay the bill n ill type whatever you want

lol

alice
mainer
Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

brillke, you have over 1k posts

what do you have to say about yourself





I say, boy are my fingers getting tired.

brillke




1000 posts ! And we love all of them




brille n still going tick tick like timex lol you go girl

alice
mainer
Quote:

Quote:

Just read this in the EW interview with Tim Gunn.

"Any other behind-the-scenes scoop that we didn't see on TV?

Vincent, my heartthrob — no, I'm teasing. If I were to say that with seriousness, put a bullet in my head. What you didn't see is when we were taping the reunion show, after that clip with Vincent, Michael Rucker, the producer who was in the scene with him doing all the screaming and yelling, came out to present him with a whole stack of new shirts, which was really lovely. And as soon as we broke for commercial, Vincent stood up and walked them to a garbage can and dumped them. He's crazy."



Wow,speaks volumes about the guy, huh? He was so gracious about them on the reunion show. He seemed very pleased yet he turns around and does this?

brillke






I saw this side of Vincent in the way he treated Angela. I sized that up and when people were saying "Oh Vincent is so sweet" I just never saw that.

He seemed very very vicious with her when she stood up to him. I am not saying that Angela was perfect, but it was Vincent's fault as he was constantly rolling his eyes at her and smirking and saying "I'm team leadah"!

Angela never really was given the benefit of the doubt by certain designers after she repudiated Vincent on the runway and said she did not like his design. Her problem is that she doesnt know how to play interpersonal politics very well. But she was clearly sabotaged by Vincent and right after Uli said she didnt want to room with Angela.

I suppose it must have been devine retribution for Angela to see how Vincent's insanity and disgusting behavior on display for all to see during the reunion show.




tam we think so much alike its scarey lol i thought i missed something in the angela/vincent pairing. i saw vincent as the nut job that really wanted no help from the get go. he was nasty from the beginning . look at his attitude in picking out the fabric she tried to point out to him they only had little time n he jumped on her. no she has her bad points but but she wasnt the villian that all thought she was. i also feel uli for all her sweetness in a sheep in wolfs clothing at times. she seemed to switch a lot of her loyalities at times n opinions as to who was in the room,. personally i dont trust people like that . IMHO

alice
tamarinden
Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

Just read this in the EW interview with Tim Gunn.

"Any other behind-the-scenes scoop that we didn't see on TV?

Vincent, my heartthrob — no, I'm teasing. If I were to say that with seriousness, put a bullet in my head. What you didn't see is when we were taping the reunion show, after that clip with Vincent, Michael Rucker, the producer who was in the scene with him doing all the screaming and yelling, came out to present him with a whole stack of new shirts, which was really lovely. And as soon as we broke for commercial, Vincent stood up and walked them to a garbage can and dumped them. He's crazy."



Wow,speaks volumes about the guy, huh? He was so gracious about them on the reunion show. He seemed very pleased yet he turns around and does this?

brillke






I saw this side of Vincent in the way he treated Angela. I sized that up and when people were saying "Oh Vincent is so sweet" I just never saw that.

He seemed very very vicious with her when she stood up to him. I am not saying that Angela was perfect, but it was Vincent's fault as he was constantly rolling his eyes at her and smirking and saying "I'm team leadah"!

Angela never really was given the benefit of the doubt by certain designers after she repudiated Vincent on the runway and said she did not like his design. Her problem is that she doesnt know how to play interpersonal politics very well. But she was clearly sabotaged by Vincent and right after Uli said she didnt want to room with Angela.

I suppose it must have been devine retribution for Angela to see how Vincent's insanity and disgusting behavior on display for all to see during the reunion show.




tam we think so much alike its scarey lol i thought i missed something in the angela/vincent pairing. i saw vincent as the nut job that really wanted no help from the get go. he was nasty from the beginning . look at his attitude in picking out the fabric she tried to point out to him they only had little time n he jumped on her. no she has her bad points but but she wasnt the villian that all thought she was. i also feel uli for all her sweetness in a sheep in wolfs clothing at times. she seemed to switch a lot of her loyalities at times n opinions as to who was in the room,. personally i dont trust people like that . IMHO

alice




Thanks, Alice, I take that as a super compliment

Did you notice how, when Angela was on Vincent's team, she sat nearby for hours and he gave her absolutely nothing to do. Malan noticed that and he was one of the few who took Angela's side.... the rest did not. Also, after hours of sitting doing nothing while the other teams worked together, Angela finally had enough and just went to amuse herself, eat, whatever. The very second she walked away, Vincent, who had given her NOTHING to do, ran screaming at the top of his lungs "ANGELA WHERE ARE YOU !!??" Everyone heard it and it looked as if Angela had just walked out in a fit of pique but that was all engineered by Vincent.

To change the subject to our Laura, did you notice how Tim hugged her when she finished showing her collection??? I think he was far more impressed by her collection than he could say. Heidi is his boss after all, and he cannot be seen openly disagreeing with the judges decisions too much.

Heidi is an enigma to me. I actually like her a lot, and Tim said that she gets very disturbed when she has to auf someone. I also did love what she said to Laura. She said some very nice things about Laura's collection.


Agreed I didnt trust Uli, until I saw her collection, and she did what I think a true artist should do, she let me see the beauty inside. As of course did Laura. This is true genius IMO. I sort of fell in love with Uli at that moment, and she is a VERY strong second behind Laura for me now.

I absolutely see her as a good, kind person, who is incredibly good at playing the political game and using it for her own advantage, but I do think inside she wouldnt hurt anyone.

It has been such a privilege for me to know the very nice people here on this forum, and I will always carry you all in my heart.
mainer
Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

Just read this in the EW interview with Tim Gunn.

"Any other behind-the-scenes scoop that we didn't see on TV?

Vincent, my heartthrob — no, I'm teasing. If I were to say that with seriousness, put a bullet in my head. What you didn't see is when we were taping the reunion show, after that clip with Vincent, Michael Rucker, the producer who was in the scene with him doing all the screaming and yelling, came out to present him with a whole stack of new shirts, which was really lovely. And as soon as we broke for commercial, Vincent stood up and walked them to a garbage can and dumped them. He's crazy."



Wow,speaks volumes about the guy, huh? He was so gracious about them on the reunion show. He seemed very pleased yet he turns around and does this?

brillke






I saw this side of Vincent in the way he treated Angela. I sized that up and when people were saying "Oh Vincent is so sweet" I just never saw that.

He seemed very very vicious with her when she stood up to him. I am not saying that Angela was perfect, but it was Vincent's fault as he was constantly rolling his eyes at her and smirking and saying "I'm team leadah"!

Angela never really was given the benefit of the doubt by certain designers after she repudiated Vincent on the runway and said she did not like his design. Her problem is that she doesnt know how to play interpersonal politics very well. But she was clearly sabotaged by Vincent and right after Uli said she didnt want to room with Angela.

I suppose it must have been devine retribution for Angela to see how Vincent's insanity and disgusting behavior on display for all to see during the reunion show.




tam we think so much alike its scarey lol i thought i missed something in the angela/vincent pairing. i saw vincent as the nut job that really wanted no help from the get go. he was nasty from the beginning . look at his attitude in picking out the fabric she tried to point out to him they only had little time n he jumped on her. no she has her bad points but but she wasnt the villian that all thought she was. i also feel uli for all her sweetness in a sheep in wolfs clothing at times. she seemed to switch a lot of her loyalities at times n opinions as to who was in the room,. personally i dont trust people like that . IMHO

alice




Thanks, Alice, I take that as a super compliment

Did you notice how, when Angela was on Vincent's team, she sat nearby for hours and he gave her absolutely nothing to do. Malan noticed that and he was one of the few who took Angela's side.... the rest did not. Also, after hours of sitting doing nothing while the other teams worked together, Angela finally had enough and just went to amuse herself, eat, whatever. The very second she walked away, Vincent, who had given her NOTHING to do, ran screaming at the top of his lungs "ANGELA WHERE ARE YOU !!??" Everyone heard it and it looked as if Angela had just walked out in a fit of pique but that was all engineered by Vincent.

To change the subject to our Laura, did you notice how Tim hugged her when she finished showing her collection??? I think he was far more impressed by her collection than he could say. Heidi is his boss after all, and he cannot be seen openly disagreeing with the judges decisions too much.

Heidi is an enigma to me. I actually like her a lot, and Tim said that she gets very disturbed when she has to auf someone. I also did love what she said to Laura. She said some very nice things about Laura's collection.


Agreed I didnt trust Uli, until I saw her collection, and she did what I think a true artist should do, she let me see the beauty inside. As of course did Laura. This is true genius IMO. I sort of fell in love with Uli at that moment, and she is a VERY strong second behind Laura for me now.

I absolutely see her as a good, kind person, who is incredibly good at playing the political game and using it for her own advantage, but I do think inside she wouldnt hurt anyone.

It has been such a privilege for me to know the very nice people here on this forum, and I will always carry you all in my heart.




thank you tam for that lovely last comment. we love you too . glad though that we will still be able to chat with you on line. if you ever come bk to the US come visit me in maine. we have plenty of room as long as you lkie pets ( no turtles though lol) dogs n cats.
i agree i dont think uli would hurt anyone as some did. also i thought both (laura n ulis) collections were stunning n flattering to women. i also notcied how laura n uli got the most applause when they were on the runway.
yep heidi is the boss unfortunatly IMHO. also saw how vincent yelled for angela the moment she left . hell i would have left to if he treated me that way. i felt she should have spoken up for herself a lot more in that regard n not take the brunt of the wrongdoing. as i have said in previous thank got jeffery n vincent didnt have me in that room. my hubby tells people shen they have a comment to anything i say "welcome to alices world". lol but really its a world of treat people how you want to be treated n dont hurt anyone. in other words we go thru this life only once be kind.

alice
oscarsimon
Quote:

Quote:

I gotta say - - I'm am completely lost on this argument "Fashion is supposed to make a woman beautiful".

Is this to say ALL must adhere to YOUR concept of beauty?

Have you ever studied or read about "beauty" around the world?

Perhaps you should.





Did you just disagree with yourself?

brillke




NO - unless you perceive from your own mind for this too mean more then it states.

But then you always do jump in to defend Tam - the one I wrote this to.
tamarinden
Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

I gotta say - - I'm am completely lost on this argument "Fashion is supposed to make a woman beautiful".

Is this to say ALL must adhere to YOUR concept of beauty?

Have you ever studied or read about "beauty" around the world?

Perhaps you should.





Did you just disagree with yourself?

brillke




NO - unless you perceive from your own mind for this too mean more then it states.

But then you always do jump in to defend Tam - the one I wrote this to.




Hi Oscarsimon

I dont event think you are quoting me there, but I will say I agree with the sentiment that fashion should make a woman beautiful. Or at least fashion should be beautiful on a woman or a man.

this is just my opinion. I have thusfar not introduced a bill in congress to force you to agree with my opinions.

I thank god Brillke and AI and Mainer do step in sometimes, because its good to know that they understand what I am talking about and realize I am not trying to dictate fashion to ANYONE. I am, like you, expressing my POV.
oscarsimon
WHO and WHAT defines beauty?

From my POV you continue to put down those who do not fit your narrow perception of beauty.

Beauty is a personal perception - - it can not be dictated.

In parts of Haiti - women wrap yards of fabric around their hips to make themselves beautiful.

Northern Japanese girls tattooed their foreheads, hands, arms, and upper lips, with a motif that stretched from ear to ear (the tattoo was completed by the groom on their honeymoon).

Some people find tatoos and spiked hair beautiful.

The classic man today is tall and thin - - - I happen to be attracted to stocky men.
oscarsimon
For those who think I might be new here - - I am not.

I have been here since the first Project Runway.

Sarcastic and snide remarks were made toward me and something I said early on - - - I chose to speak up. Simple as that.
actor59
Hi Oscarsimon,

I have been reading all the post here and there is alot of newbies that have signed up to bash the decision of the winner. I as has bear and a few other posters have been Jeffreys corner the whole time, we have not bashed the other contestants on the show..just tried to talk about the fashion. Personally I thank you for your post in regards to this last show..to me it was not you on a soap box but trying to get most posters to understand why Jeffrey won in regards to innovation etc.
As Bear stated earlier we both are in Jeffreys corner but Uli did step it up and had a great show. I thought she would win!

However I'm glad Jeffrey won.We all have our favs, Tam loves Laura and I must admitt I love those styles from the 30's,40's as well.The one thing is Tam has her opinions and being a 20yr.old college student and studying fashion she is intittalled her opinion. Loved the the poetic verse you did for her.
Too all the regular posters thank you it has been fun. We tend to dissagree and agree to dissagree with each others opinions and that it great!

Now on another point! Did anyone get a chance to see Tim Gunn host with Kelly Rippa on the Reggies and Kelly show yesterday? If you did not then you missed a truley great show!!!!! Love me some Tim Gunn.
tamarinden
Quote:

WHO and WHAT defines beauty?

From my POV you continue to put down those who do not fit your narrow perception of beauty.

Beauty is a personal perception - - it can not be dictated.

In parts of Haiti - women wrap yards of fabric around their hips to make themselves beautiful.

Northern Japanese girls tattooed their foreheads, hands, arms, and upper lips, with a motif that stretched from ear to ear (the tattoo was completed by the groom on their honeymoon).

Some people find tatoos and spiked hair beautiful.

The classic man today is tall and thin - - - I happen to be attracted to stocky men.










I am done with your rudeness

I am not telling ANYONE what to consider beautful, but you just keep continually following me about harrassing me.

I think you are probably simplebear to be honest, but in any event I dont care who you are. I have a POV and I will present it and if you dont like what I have to say then just read past and move on.

I consider you a TROLL and this is my last response to you.
actor59
Mornin Tam!,

I value your opinion!
tamarinden
Quote:

Mornin Tam!,

I value your opinion!




good morning Actor I hope you are feeling better and that things are looking up. I thought of you when Jeffrey won and wanted very badly to congratulate you and tell you what a lovely collection he had. I hope all is better now
mainer
Quote:

WHO and WHAT defines beauty?

From my POV you continue to put down those who do not fit your narrow perception of beauty.

Beauty is a personal perception - - it can not be dictated.

In parts of Haiti - women wrap yards of fabric around their hips to make themselves beautiful.

Northern Japanese girls tattooed their foreheads, hands, arms, and upper lips, with a motif that stretched from ear to ear (the tattoo was completed by the groom on their honeymoon).

Some people find tatoos and spiked hair beautiful.

The classic man today is tall and thin - - - I happen to be attracted to stocky men.

not all men today are tall n thin very few of ordinary males. tattoos are beauty to some but not to all. depends
beauty is in the eye of the beholder. n all are entitled to their own opinion even here. coninuing to argue for the sake of some one not agreeing with u is pointless
so to you who seems to like to agrue finit

alice







TishTheFish
Quote:

Quote:

WHO and WHAT defines beauty?

From my POV you continue to put down those who do not fit your narrow perception of beauty.

Beauty is a personal perception - - it can not be dictated.

In parts of Haiti - women wrap yards of fabric around their hips to make themselves beautiful.

Northern Japanese girls tattooed their foreheads, hands, arms, and upper lips, with a motif that stretched from ear to ear (the tattoo was completed by the groom on their honeymoon).

Some people find tatoos and spiked hair beautiful.

The classic man today is tall and thin - - - I happen to be attracted to stocky men.










I am done with your rudeness

I am not telling ANYONE what to consider beautful, but you just keep continually following me about harrassing me.

I think you are probably simplebear to be honest, but in any event I dont care who you are. I have a POV and I will present it and if you dont like what I have to say then just read past and move on.

I consider you a TROLL and this is my last response to you.




There must be much more to your posting relationship than the above to illicit such a strong response. I don't think anyone's POV should be dismissed as uninformed/trite/unworthy but we can disagree. I hope you two can accept that your POV can be challenged by others without dismissing you personally.
tamarinden
Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

WHO and WHAT defines beauty?

From my POV you continue to put down those who do not fit your narrow perception of beauty.

Beauty is a personal perception - - it can not be dictated.

In parts of Haiti - women wrap yards of fabric around their hips to make themselves beautiful.

Northern Japanese girls tattooed their foreheads, hands, arms, and upper lips, with a motif that stretched from ear to ear (the tattoo was completed by the groom on their honeymoon).

Some people find tatoos and spiked hair beautiful.

The classic man today is tall and thin - - - I happen to be attracted to stocky men.










I am done with your rudeness

I am not telling ANYONE what to consider beautful, but you just keep continually following me about harrassing me.

I think you are probably simplebear to be honest, but in any event I dont care who you are. I have a POV and I will present it and if you dont like what I have to say then just read past and move on.

I consider you a TROLL and this is my last response to you.




There must be much more to your posting relationship than the above to illicit such a strong response. I don't think anyone's POV should be dismissed as uninformed/trite/unworthy but we can disagree. I hope you two can accept that your POV can be challenged by others without dismissing you personally.




are you addressing this to me? Please show me a post in which I got personal with anyone who disagreed with my POV ?

I have had words when people are rude but never with anyone's ideas. Oscarsimon is coming from some planet I do not know.
actor59
Thanks Tam for me being in your thoughts! AI and Brillke read about the deaths of my friends in the papers I'm sure it did make national news. Was a truley horrific thing that happened that makes all of this stupid bashing I've read on the boards in regards to the show seem very light, compared to the extremely dark thing that happened here in NOLA.
But the posters on this board have let me escape from the reality that has happened here.
I'm sorry your fav did not win but I loved her collection. I loved all the collections. But as they said on ProjectRunGay the peanut head won...lol
tamarinden
Quote:

Thanks Tam for me being in your thoughts! AI and Brillke read about the deaths of my friends in the papers I'm sure it did make national news. Was a truley horrific thing that happened that makes all of this stupid bashing I've read on the boards in regards to the show seem very light, compared to the extremely dark thing that happened here in NOLA.
But the posters on this board have let me escape from the reality that has happened here.
I'm sorry your fav did not win but I loved her collection. I loved all the collections. But as they said on ProjectRunGay the peanut head won...lol




After seeing all the attacks on Jeffrey after winning, I am very content that neither Laura or Uli won. I am happier in fact that they did not.

The primary objective was to show at fashion week. In that sense they are all winners I think all will have great careers in fashion. I am too emotionally invested in the collections of Laura and Uli, and it would be very painful to read the horrible things about them that people have posted about Jeffrey since winning. I am less invested in Jeffrey's clothes, so its easier to take.

I enjoyed all the collections (michaels not so much).

Am very sorry about the tragedy that you have endured. I saw the news about the deaths in N.O. and I wondered if these were the same people you mentioned the night you left.
beechlapper
Quote:

Quote:


You missed my point.

Someone who has watched two seasons of Project Runway episodes on television is in no position to judge or compare the designers work.

Someone who has had the opportunity to look at their work first hand is in a better position to know who does better work.




Actually no I didn't miss your point. I disagreed with it. And fashion is designed for people like me, so yes I am in a position to judge what I do and don't consider fashionable. From what I've been reading on here so far, the vast majority seem to agree with me. Even if Heidi did see the creations close up, she was still obviously blind to good taste.




The discussion was never whether fashion was designed for you or not. Nor was the discussion ever about what you do and do not consider fashionable or even whether you were in a position to decide what was fashionable to you or not.

The statement in question was whether Chloe was a better designer than Jeffrey. Questions relating to whether you prefer one's designs or the other's are irrelevant. No one was talking about taste. In a similar vein, having more people agree with you doesn't mean you are right. It only means that your answer is more popular. If the majority of an algebra class come up with X=4 and Y=2 as an answer to a problem, it does not make the answer right. In the same vein, lack of commercial success does not equal failure. Some people may choose to not go the commercial success route because they may have to give up their creative integrity. Success means different things to each of us. For some artists, it is being true to yourself without selling out.

Just because someone makes mistakes in one area does not mean they can't be an expert in another. Not everyone can be an expert at everything. So if Heidi puts on a godawful outfit one day, it doesn't mean she is not in a position to know what constitutes good fashion. Her years in the business of modelling give her credibility and there is no doubt she can recognize good form and construction from a mile away.

My statement still stands, Heidi Klum is in a better position to judge (because she has seen the garments up close and because of her modelling experience) whether Chloe or Jeffrey is the better designer than someone who has just watched an edited view of the garments marched on a runway for five minutes on a television program.

That doesn't mean you can not decide whose clothes you like better - but that is not what determines who is the better designer.
actor59
Yup they were..Terribly sad.

Oh by the way did you see Tim Gunn on the Reggies/Kelly show yesterday? He c0-hosted with Kelly and she made him put on those croc shoes! I was ROTFLMAO when he was standing there in his lovely suit and tie with those ugly green rubber looking crocs on his feet. Started my whole morning off with a great laugh really needed that.
tamarinden
Quote:

Yup they were..Terribly sad.

Oh by the way did you see Tim Gunn on the Reggies/Kelly show yesterday? He c0-hosted with Kelly and she made him put on those croc shoes! I was ROTFLMAO when he was standing there in his lovely suit and tie with those ugly green rubber looking crocs on his feet. Started my whole morning off with a great laugh really needed that.




LOL no I didnt see that Would love to have seen it !
CALady
Quote:

Quote:

Yup they were..Terribly sad.

Oh by the way did you see Tim Gunn on the Reggies/Kelly show yesterday? He c0-hosted with Kelly and she made him put on those croc shoes! I was ROTFLMAO when he was standing there in his lovely suit and tie with those ugly green rubber looking crocs on his feet. Started my whole morning off with a great laugh really needed that.




LOL no I didnt see that Would love to have seen it !




Good morning Tam and Actor.
Well it is still morning out here.
I too missed seeing Tim with Kelly. I bet he was great.
actor59
Was so funny because he just ripped on and on about how everyone was wearing them in NYC and he thought they were so ugly and he just did not understand it? Ofcourse Tim used alot of $3 words to describe his hate of the crocs..lol..but after standing in them while audience gave him a standing ovation for putting them on....after the applause died down , he looked down at the crocs and said " But Oh my, they are comfortable"...lol. I was laughing so hard I almost peed my pants.
actor59
Morning CALady,

Sorry you missed the show I got to see it before going to work! And yes, he was great think he has a great future as a co-host or host of his own show would be great to see that. But I doubt he ever would, he just kept saying he was so nervous about co-hosting with Kelly and was in such awe to be there doing it. The audience really loved him.
brillke
Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

I gotta say - - I'm am completely lost on this argument "Fashion is supposed to make a woman beautiful".

Is this to say ALL must adhere to YOUR concept of beauty?

Have you ever studied or read about "beauty" around the world?

Perhaps you should.





Did you just disagree with yourself?

brillke




NO - unless you perceive from your own mind for this too mean more then it states.

But then you always do jump in to defend Tam - the one I wrote this to.





Hun, go back to the post you wrote. Your were replying to yourself. Your obsession with tam is so bad that you see her name instead of yours?

brillke
CALady
Quote:

Morning CALady,

Sorry you missed the show I got to see it before going to work! And yes, he was great think he has a great future as a co-host or host of his own show would be great to see that. But I doubt he ever would, he just kept saying he was so nervous about co-hosting with Kelly and was in such awe to be there doing it. The audience really loved him.




Oh a Tim show would be wonderful. We all need a Tim in our lives... what a wonderful world that would be.

No pressure Tim. LOL
Carole
Just hooking on here to say how glad I was to see my old friends still here this morning...I am really going to miss posting with my "buds" on this board. I have tried twice now to watch TC but just am not going to get into it...for one thing, how can people possibly eat snails...so I guess I will have to wait another year to greet everyone again. I hope you all take good care of your health and see you back for PR 4!
CALady
Quote:

Just hooking on here to say how glad I was to see my old friends still here this morning...I am really going to miss posting with my "buds" on this board. I have tried twice now to watch TC but just am not going to get into it...for one thing, how can people possibly eat snails...so I guess I will have to wait another year to greet everyone again. I hope you all take good care of your health and see you back for PR 4!




Oh Carole, We would hate to see you wait until S4. Give TC a chance, it took me two or three shows the first season and now I am hooked. I learned so much about cooking that I really enjoy it now and the drama was fun as well.
If not, stop by the TC board and chat with us.
actor59
Afternoon Brillke!
I know it is only a little after noon here but could you pass me some PR punch and a cheeseburger?
CALady
Quote:

Afternoon Brillke!
I know it is only a little after noon here but could you pass me some PR punch and a cheeseburger?




I agree with Actor... let's get this post show party going.
actor59
LOL Carol,

Give TC another chance...it really is a great show if you like cooking that is....and I love snails if they are done right...lol but then again I'm a Jeffrey lover..LOL
oscarsimon
Quote:

Hi Oscarsimon,

I have been reading all the post here and there is alot of newbies that have signed up to bash the decision of the winner. I as has bear and a few other posters have been Jeffreys corner the whole time, we have not bashed the other contestants on the show..just tried to talk about the fashion. Personally I thank you for your post in regards to this last show..to me it was not you on a soap box but trying to get most posters to understand why Jeffrey won in regards to innovation etc.
As Bear stated earlier we both are in Jeffreys corner but Uli did step it up and had a great show. I thought she would win!

However I'm glad Jeffrey won.We all have our favs, Tam loves Laura and I must admitt I love those styles from the 30's,40's as well.The one thing is Tam has her opinions and being a 20yr.old college student and studying fashion she is intittalled her opinion. Loved the the poetic verse you did for her.

Too all the regular posters thank you it has been fun. We tend to dissagree and agree to dissagree with each others opinions and that it great!

Now on another point! Did anyone get a chance to see Tim Gunn host with Kelly Rippa on the Reggies and Kelly show yesterday? If you did not then you missed a truley great show!!!!! Love me some Tim Gunn.




Thank you Actor59

If you read most of my posts - - they are logical - - direct - - and void of emotion - - not bashing at all.

I have participated on many forums and over the years have learned to be staid - - using a more logical opinion assessment rather then personal feelings (however I am human).

I have clearly stated (more then once) Uli's designs are beautiful and the only clothes that I would personally buy for myself.

I have clearly stated Laura is the best seamstress - - her workmanship is undeniable - - and her designs are of classic beauty (we all know of the little black dress).

I have stated clearly all three did great in their own style - - but that Jeffrey had more range - innovation - creativity (which is exactly why the judges chose him).

I am appalled by the personal attacks.

Now - - being that I am 60 and grew up in the Venice Beach CA area - - I do have a fondness for "funky" street styles.

However - - I have been designing and constructing clothes since I was six and sell/buy vintage. I have knowledge of many styles and eras. And I am very aware of construction and coulture.

Only because of sarcastic and snide remarks directed to a post I made (actually more then one) - - did I come out of the woodwork - - where I had been silently reading.

One who expressed their opinion in an offensive manner and specifically directed it - - is responsible for me becoming vocal in my own defense.

Should I have let it go? Probably

Should I have retreated before now? Probably

But - I chose to continue. Wrong decision? Yes (but I am only human)
tamarinden
Quote:

Quote:

Hi Oscarsimon,

I have been reading all the post here and there is alot of newbies that have signed up to bash the decision of the winner. I as has bear and a few other posters have been Jeffreys corner the whole time, we have not bashed the other contestants on the show..just tried to talk about the fashion. Personally I thank you for your post in regards to this last show..to me it was not you on a soap box but trying to get most posters to understand why Jeffrey won in regards to innovation etc.
As Bear stated earlier we both are in Jeffreys corner but Uli did step it up and had a great show. I thought she would win!

However I'm glad Jeffrey won.We all have our favs, Tam loves Laura and I must admitt I love those styles from the 30's,40's as well.The one thing is Tam has her opinions and being a 20yr.old college student and studying fashion she is intittalled her opinion. Loved the the poetic verse you did for her.

Too all the regular posters thank you it has been fun. We tend to dissagree and agree to dissagree with each others opinions and that it great!

Now on another point! Did anyone get a chance to see Tim Gunn host with Kelly Rippa on the Reggies and Kelly show yesterday? If you did not then you missed a truley great show!!!!! Love me some Tim Gunn.




Thank you Actor59

If you read most of my posts - - they are logical - - direct - - and void of emotion - - not bashing at all.

I have participated on many forums and over the years have learned to be staid - - using a more logical opinion assessment rather then personal feelings (however I am human).

I have clearly stated (more then once) Uli's designs are beautiful and the only clothes that I would personally buy for myself.

I have clearly stated Laura is the best seamstress - - her workmanship is undeniable - - and her designs are of classic beauty (we all know of the little black dress).

I have stated clearly all three did great in their own style - - but that Jeffrey had more range - innovation - creativity (which is exactly why the judges chose him).

I am appalled by the personal attacks.

Now - - being that I am 60 and grew up in the Venice Beach CA area - - I do have a fondness for "funky" street styles.

However - - I have been designing and constructing clothes since I was six and sell/buy vintage. I have knowledge of many styles and eras. And I am very aware of construction and coulture.

Only because of sarcastic and snide remarks directed to a post I made (actually more then one) - - did I come out of the woodwork - - where I had been silently reading.

One who expressed their opinion in an offensive manner and specifically directed it - - is responsible for me becoming vocal in my own defense.

Should I have let it go? Probably

Should I have retreated before now? Probably

But - I chose to continue. Wrong decision? Yes (but I am only human)










I loved that poetry too Oscarsimon. It was so vivid and beautiful what you wrote, I was truly unable to express words.

It touched me deeply, and I should have said something, but nothing I could have posted would be equal to what you wrote.

I did get snide with you once but I have asked several times your forgiveness. I honestly do not know what to think.
You sometimes post lovely things, and sometimes angry things (I guess I do that too) but somehow I cannot tell if you see in me a target or a friend. It does seem a target at times, but I could be misunderstanding you.

I will always read what you write, I enjoy your posts, except when you quote someone else thinking it was me. I do think you have confused some negative things someone else has said for my own words, but then maybe not.
actor59
That was why the compliment...but I could also see the bashing going on...I really did not get you as a Jeffrey advocate but trying to be a voice of reason to the bashers....and Tam is not one....she really has put in some excellent post during the season. She was sad her fav did not win but I do have to say she has never attacked Jeffreys designs just his attitude.
There have been some flame wars between posters but I think all things are said and done everyone calms down and goes OH! now I get what your trying to say. But because of all the newbies that just through their disgust out there, your post imo was like trying to spit in the wind to put it politely. But since I had a shock to my everyday life I could not post until yesterday and today. If you noticed most of the regular posters stayed away from the boards and were not involved with all the newbies. I love post were they try to explain about fashion shows and not about every day wear. But as I said it was like trying to spit in the wind. And I think you did try to make up to TAM by that beautiful prose you wrote for her.
If we could stop attacking posters as alot of the trolls do it would be a nice world on the boards... but that is the boards trolls and all...lol
Tankthemoroncat
Quote:



I have been reading all the post here and there is alot of newbies that have signed up to bash the decision of the winner. I as has bear and a few other posters have been Jeffreys corner the whole time, we have not bashed the other contestants on the show..just tried to talk about the fashion. Personally I thank you for your post in regards to this last show..to me it was not you on a soap box but trying to get most posters to understand why Jeffrey won in regards to innovation etc.
As Bear stated earlier we both are in Jeffreys corner but Uli did step it up and had a great show. I thought she would win!

However I'm glad Jeffrey won.We all have our favs, Tam loves Laura and I must admitt I love those styles from the 30's,40's as well.The one thing is Tam has her opinions and being a 20yr.old college student and studying fashion she is intittalled her opinion. Loved the the poetic verse you did for her.
Too all the regular posters thank you it has been fun. We tend to dissagree and agree to dissagree with each others opinions and that it great!

Now on another point! Did anyone get a chance to see Tim Gunn host with Kelly Rippa on the Reggies and Kelly show yesterday? If you did not then you missed a truley great show!!!!! Love me some Tim Gunn.




It amazes me how you always have a great way of saying stuff. I also loved Laura's collection. I just understand the judges' point of view for the winner. I had them placed exactly right how they placed them.

I can't believe I missed Tim!!!! I love Tim! He's so suave and debonair! and so cute as he's being handed poop! LOL!

I made the same point about what is pretty, also, oscarsimon. I think people see things only in their own perspective. Sometimes we have to walk in someone else's shoes.

Fashion is and always has been a statement of who we are. That might be culturally or socially. Jeffrey's mindset is punk/rebellious and that includes "new" and "different" or not conforming to what others do...... THAT is what PR wanted. Not what we want, not what most people will wear, but they wanted to see just how creative one could be and the most creative won.

Some who do not see the reasoning are looking at it in too broad of a sense - they need to scale the idea down to the one tent, the one idea of what would be fashion in that tent, and what it represented.

Commenting on a WAYyyyy back issue in this thread - Jeffrey had his people sign confidentiality statements incase they saw his designs - they were working nearby so it makes sense to me!
oscarsimon
Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

Hi Oscarsimon,

I have been reading all the post here and there is alot of newbies that have signed up to bash the decision of the winner. I as has bear and a few other posters have been Jeffreys corner the whole time, we have not bashed the other contestants on the show..just tried to talk about the fashion. Personally I thank you for your post in regards to this last show..to me it was not you on a soap box but trying to get most posters to understand why Jeffrey won in regards to innovation etc.
As Bear stated earlier we both are in Jeffreys corner but Uli did step it up and had a great show. I thought she would win!

However I'm glad Jeffrey won.We all have our favs, Tam loves Laura and I must admitt I love those styles from the 30's,40's as well.The one thing is Tam has her opinions and being a 20yr.old college student and studying fashion she is intittalled her opinion. Loved the the poetic verse you did for her.

Too all the regular posters thank you it has been fun. We tend to dissagree and agree to dissagree with each others opinions and that it great!

Now on another point! Did anyone get a chance to see Tim Gunn host with Kelly Rippa on the Reggies and Kelly show yesterday? If you did not then you missed a truley great show!!!!! Love me some Tim Gunn.




Thank you Actor59

If you read most of my posts - - they are logical - - direct - - and void of emotion - - not bashing at all.

I have participated on many forums and over the years have learned to be staid - - using a more logical opinion assessment rather then personal feelings (however I am human).

I have clearly stated (more then once) Uli's designs are beautiful and the only clothes that I would personally buy for myself.

I have clearly stated Laura is the best seamstress - - her workmanship is undeniable - - and her designs are of classic beauty (we all know of the little black dress).

I have stated clearly all three did great in their own style - - but that Jeffrey had more range - innovation - creativity (which is exactly why the judges chose him).

I am appalled by the personal attacks.

Now - - being that I am 60 and grew up in the Venice Beach CA area - - I do have a fondness for "funky" street styles.

However - - I have been designing and constructing clothes since I was six and sell/buy vintage. I have knowledge of many styles and eras. And I am very aware of construction and coulture.

Only because of sarcastic and snide remarks directed to a post I made (actually more then one) - - did I come out of the woodwork - - where I had been silently reading.

One who expressed their opinion in an offensive manner and specifically directed it - - is responsible for me becoming vocal in my own defense.

Should I have let it go? Probably

Should I have retreated before now? Probably

But - I chose to continue. Wrong decision? Yes (but I am only human)










I loved that poetry too Oscarsimon. It was so vivid and beautiful what you wrote, I was truly unable to express words.

It touched me deeply, and I should have said something, but nothing I could have posted would be equal to what you wrote.

I did get snide with you once but I have asked several times your forgiveness. I honestly do not know what to think.
You sometimes post lovely things, and sometimes angry things (I guess I do that too) but somehow I cannot tell if you see in me a target or a friend. It does seem a target at times, but I could be misunderstanding you.

I will always read what you write, I enjoy your posts, except when you quote someone else thinking it was me. I do think you have confused some negative things someone else has said for my own words, but then maybe not.




OK - TRUCE

I can do that. Fashion has been my life - I can be a bit sensitive.

Happy that you liked what I wrote especially for you. It is original - written only on this board - for you (see I can be sweet too).

I wanted you to take great positive creative thoughts with you to design school.

Fashion is Everything.
ArtInstigator
Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

After watching the runway show, I thought for sure that Jeffrey should have won. Why can't you people put aside your dislike for his personality to see that he really did have the best, cohesive collection? I didn't care for him personally either, but...




I can't stand his clothes, no matter what his personality is...Uli clearly should have won.




No she shouldn't have.

The right person won.




You know Oscarsimon,
It's your posts like this that I find offensive. You complain about others getting snide with you, but you're kinda bossy with your opinion. The original post was from rtrack and the response was from mchris65. Did either one of these posters personally attack you?
AI
actor59
Thanks Tank for that....I really find it funny as to how I'm a straight, white 47yr.old man, who has never sewn a stch in his life on a sewing machine or bought extremly fashionable clothes...that I'm so hooked into this show! Have been since the very first year.
I have given this alot of thought and try to express my opinions without kicking some other posters teeth in..lol
I think the reason I love this show so much is it really makes me think about the creative process that goes on in each of the designers minds. To take it from thought and try to apply it to the realization of the outcome of the dress that will be done. And then focus on that and create that gown. It is too me like reading a script and imagining that charecture and getting what comes out of my head and imagination and makeing that charecture come to life for the audience for the theatre or film.

Yes the drama is fun on the show and these are real designers but the process is very close to what I experience creating a charecture.

Off my lecturine now...lol
tamarinden
Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

Hi Oscarsimon,

I have been reading all the post here and there is alot of newbies that have signed up to bash the decision of the winner. I as has bear and a few other posters have been Jeffreys corner the whole time, we have not bashed the other contestants on the show..just tried to talk about the fashion. Personally I thank you for your post in regards to this last show..to me it was not you on a soap box but trying to get most posters to understand why Jeffrey won in regards to innovation etc.
As Bear stated earlier we both are in Jeffreys corner but Uli did step it up and had a great show. I thought she would win!

However I'm glad Jeffrey won.We all have our favs, Tam loves Laura and I must admitt I love those styles from the 30's,40's as well.The one thing is Tam has her opinions and being a 20yr.old college student and studying fashion she is intittalled her opinion. Loved the the poetic verse you did for her.

Too all the regular posters thank you it has been fun. We tend to dissagree and agree to dissagree with each others opinions and that it great!

Now on another point! Did anyone get a chance to see Tim Gunn host with Kelly Rippa on the Reggies and Kelly show yesterday? If you did not then you missed a truley great show!!!!! Love me some Tim Gunn.




Thank you Actor59

If you read most of my posts - - they are logical - - direct - - and void of emotion - - not bashing at all.

I have participated on many forums and over the years have learned to be staid - - using a more logical opinion assessment rather then personal feelings (however I am human).

I have clearly stated (more then once) Uli's designs are beautiful and the only clothes that I would personally buy for myself.

I have clearly stated Laura is the best seamstress - - her workmanship is undeniable - - and her designs are of classic beauty (we all know of the little black dress).

I have stated clearly all three did great in their own style - - but that Jeffrey had more range - innovation - creativity (which is exactly why the judges chose him).

I am appalled by the personal attacks.

Now - - being that I am 60 and grew up in the Venice Beach CA area - - I do have a fondness for "funky" street styles.

However - - I have been designing and constructing clothes since I was six and sell/buy vintage. I have knowledge of many styles and eras. And I am very aware of construction and coulture.

Only because of sarcastic and snide remarks directed to a post I made (actually more then one) - - did I come out of the woodwork - - where I had been silently reading.

One who expressed their opinion in an offensive manner and specifically directed it - - is responsible for me becoming vocal in my own defense.

Should I have let it go? Probably

Should I have retreated before now? Probably

But - I chose to continue. Wrong decision? Yes (but I am only human)










I loved that poetry too Oscarsimon. It was so vivid and beautiful what you wrote, I was truly unable to express words.

It touched me deeply, and I should have said something, but nothing I could have posted would be equal to what you wrote.

I did get snide with you once but I have asked several times your forgiveness. I honestly do not know what to think.
You sometimes post lovely things, and sometimes angry things (I guess I do that too) but somehow I cannot tell if you see in me a target or a friend. It does seem a target at times, but I could be misunderstanding you.

I will always read what you write, I enjoy your posts, except when you quote someone else thinking it was me. I do think you have confused some negative things someone else has said for my own words, but then maybe not.




OK - TRUCE

I can do that. Fashion has been my life - I can be a bit sensitive.

Happy that you liked what I wrote especially for you. It is original - written only on this board - for you (see I can be sweet too).

I wanted you to take great positive creative thoughts with you to design school.

Fashion is Everything.






a poem for oscarsimon

La mélodie que je ne chante pas
Elle est séduisante sous tes lèvres
Les rayon de soleil desfois ne trouve que les ténèbres
Lors du coucher du soleil me moi j entends
Et de temps en temps je te comprendrai
Cher vent qui est venu sauver le désert


you are right. Fashion is everything. For me beauty is fashion, but not just physical beauty. I saw an american movie a few days ago and i cried. it was called "the grapes of wrath" by Steinbeck.

There was a scene with a withered old farm woman as she lookd into the mirror. As she saw in the mirror the ravages that poverty had done to her face over the years, it was possible to see in her face the sadness for her lost youth and loveliness. But what we saw, who looked at her, was the shining beauty of her soul as she stared into that mirror.

I cried and my boyfriend said whats wrong why are you crying Tam? And i said "because that is the most beautiful woman I have ever seen."

So please forgive me when I say that fashion is about beauty for me, for me beauty is so much more than a young model, its so many things. I think most of all, this is your disappointment in me, because you think me perhaps shallow. In any event, TRUCE
ArtInstigator
OK,
Oscarsimon,
My apologies. I'm glad you called a truce with Tam. I don't want to get into it with anyone on the board. Your opinion is yours, and mine is mine. Respect works both ways.
AI
actor59
Hey AI!,

LOL we are all mother hens when it comes to TAM! Oscarsimon and TAM did not understand each other , well they did but I think there was so much flameing go on with one time posters they got confused and thought the other posted something to them when that was not the case.And as I stated earlier Oscarsimon was trying to be the voice of reason amongst a whirlwind of first time trolls...lol...thank god she was only spitting in the wind and not trying to piss in the wind that would of been messy for her...lol
oscarsimon
Thank you for the poem.

Yes - beauty in all things. The soul is the birth place.
tamarinden
Quote:

OK,
Oscarsimon,
My apologies. I'm glad you called a truce with Tam. I don't want to get into it with anyone on the board. Your opinion is yours, and mine is mine. Respect works both ways.
AI




Thank you for being my friend AI. I value your fearlessness and honesty and you are very dear to me.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.