QUOTE (SivartAlappes @ May 1, 2008 - 10:34 AM)

...
1)Open-Face Italian Breakfast Sandwich: 2 thick slices of Italian bread grilled on both sides, 3 eggs seasonsed beautifully (while in the pan) with salt, pepper, gradulated garlic, and fresh parsley and cooked over-medium. The eggs are then laid overtop the grilled bread and then garnished with whole parsley leaf.
2)Spicey Talapia Italiano: Pan-seared talapia tat's then steamed in a pizza sauce and white wine mixture with green asparagus, pepper, minced garlic, and crushed red pepper seeds. When plated, it's toped with a pinch of un-melted, shredded mozz cheese and more crushed red pepper seeds.
So vote! Which dish to I make for Top Chef?
Definitely #2. Not fully knowing the recipes/ingredients, I wasn't quite sure of the degree of difficulty. But, I have to say the second offering, though more ingredients, doesn't strike me as difficult, per se. Maybe more time intensive/sensitive.
Again, I don't know what you've tried-and-true tested and what you've tweaked over time, so bear with me, I'm just thinking out loud, so to speak: I'm having difficulty visualizing the first dish.
One, I'm not sure that granulated garlic is enough of an Italian reference ingredient to actually put "Italian" in the name of the dish. If, perhaps, you were to make some Italian version of ranchos nuevos with a roasted tomato and basil jam, then I could make the connection.
Two, I'm having problems imagining the mouth feel and intensity of granulated garlic as a top seasoning on eggs. If you were to rub garlic (roasted or raw) on the grilled bread, then I'd think you'd be on to something. Granulated garlic,
to me & me only!
, needs to marry with flavors and almost dissolve into something, like a sauce or a meat rub that gets "melted" into the meat.
Again, just some things that ran through my mind. They're your recipes. You know how they taste!
FWIW, I think both sound very good. ^5