SimonBao
April 25, 2008 - 11:01 AM
QUOTE (helencrump @ April 25, 2008 - 11:47 AM)

Dear SimonBao, I think the devotion is admirable . . . as it would be with any couple.
But the continual whiney vocalization of it was wearing on my last nerve. I think one poster put it this way: my grandparents love each other, but my grandfather doesn't talk about my grandmother all the time, and profess his undying love at every turn.
On the other hand, some of Jennifer's Zoi comments were made during interviews . . . meaning not in the kitchen for everyone to hear . . . some were voice over . . . meaning who knows when she said it . . . and some may have been played again and again, per the editor's choice.
So, maybe I'm not so much sick of Jennifer's Zoi comments as I am sick of hearing Jennifer's Zoi comments.
Helen, I do need to point out something that I think you may just not be considering.
In each and every "Confessional" session, in each and every episode of Top Chef throughout all 4 seasons, ever contestant has been sitting there being taped as they respond to questions being put to them by Magical Elves staff.
Those "Confessional" sessions actually go on for some great length, with the chefs being questioned, asked probing follow up questions, asked to elaborate on what they said about this dish or that competitor or their feelings about this and that.
Chefs are not just sat down in front of a rolling video camera and asked if they got something on their minds.
No, the producers hit them with a list of questions specifically crafted to elicit responses that *might* make good TV once they go into the editing room.
So I think it is not fair for anyone to complain about whatever Jen may have said. She said all those things in answer to questions she was asked.
For that matter, things that Spike says may be damn odd but he is saying them in response to specific questions being put to him.
Put me into a "Confessional" session every day and keep asking me each time about Ma'Honey and Love Of My Life, and you'll end up with hours of annoying video of me being all gushy and devoted and lovey dovey. Hell, I'd shoot the TV before I'd sit and watch that cr@p.
But, this use of "Confessional" sessions to try to elicit comments that elevate drama and push the narrative, that's at least as old as Season 3 of Real World. My first ever introduction to reality/non-fiction dramas. THey haven't changed and they haven't improved.