This is how everyone ranks with me so far:
1)Jay- Jay, Jay, Jay....where do I start? He's so cute, he's got style and sass leaking out of his ears (that white fur coat get-up? Gorgeous!)...he's had the best one liners in the whole show, with the best one being "I didn't take the b***h's dye, that's for sho!" and I also liked it when he said, "I'm not a liar or a stealer, but I wanna be one, and I wanna play one on TV!" He knows he's on TV and he's just turning on the sass! I have fallen for Jay! I like his designs too. He just keeps getting better! His first dress was "eh," his Envy outfit was edgy and cool, and his third dress was just stunning! He was able to eke out a dress that fit the theme, look great and "completely complete," and not compromise who he is. All I can say about Jay is: More!

2)Austin- As far as I'm concerned, he's the best designer there. His first dress was the best cross section of Innovation, unique material, good execution, and keeping a wearable "Night On The Town" quality. I am just in awe of his Envy dress! The slinky, dark beauty....the fluid, slithering walk and baby face w/ attitude of Martinique...it became more than a dress and became a vision for me....I ADORE it! And, once again, I don't know what the judges were talking about with his third dress...I thought his rose dress was just stunning! And he already said up front that he was going for a sort of daytime, party dress, so you can't fault him for false advertising or anything. love ya, Austin! *kiss kiss*.

3)Robert- Actually, with me, Robert and Nora are kind of on equal footing, but Robert edges out Nora because...well...he's the sexy one. He's so gorgeous and infectious, but he is infectious while being himself and not by building himself up like Daniel. I just love everey second that I get to look at Robert's beautiful face. Now....his designs. His first dress was disappointing and boring, his Envy outfit was a little safe, and his third dress was a mess of conflicting concepts. Still, as far as people/personalities go, he's right up there for me.
4)Nora- I have fallen for Nora. She is so cute, she has a lovely, goofy personality, a great sense of style, and some great designs! Her first dress was innovative right down to the choice of material (a lawn chair and place mats? way to think outside the box!). I don't know what the judges were thinking about, attacking her Envy dress. Brevity is the soul of wit (or however that saying goes) and I thought her Envy concept was subtle and well realized. It was complete and looked great. And it wasn't a cancer dress. Her third dress was just another feather in her bandana.
5)Kevin- I love Kevin. He's really cute in an offbeat way and I have been charmed by him. I adore him. However, he's a ghost on the show. It's like, "Wait, was that Kevin?" and there he goes. Except for the Missing Dye and the Starr's Not Subtle! incidents, he hasn't gotten much screentime, but like I said with Kara, so what? He's been very professional and had some solid designs. I thought his first dress was cute with the big bow, but didn't think it was very "Night On The Town"-ish. I liked his Envy dress, but didn't feel he conveyed Envy very well. I thought his third dress was fabulous and can't wait to see more Kevin as the numbers thin.
6)Mario- Mario's another cutie pie, but with a bit of a darker, more blase' side and I loved it. I thought his first dress was very elegant and I loved (and still love) his Envy dress....but I do agree that he didn't challenge himself enough. Still, I wanna see more Mario!
7)Kara- I kinda feel like she's walking one path with her designs....sort of like Alexandra, but Kara is showing more variety and creativity. I've loved all of her outfits, particularly the first one. I'm glad she won the second challenge, although I still like Austin's Envy dress the best. She is very poised and professional and like Tim has posted, her great ability is how she is able to stand back and be objective about her work. Maybe she's too safe and professional? She hasn't made for great TV yet, but who cares? She is a strong contender and a lovely woman.
8)Vanessa- I disliked Vanessa for some reason in the beginning, but she's grown on me.

I loved her first dress and thought it showed innovation and was kinda wearable. I was initially put off by her choice for the second dress, but I think it has a sort of noble quality to it(accentuating beauty in pregnancy) and I now love it. Her third dress didn't jump out at me the same way as her first two, but she is showing variety and she has a fun personality. I like her.

9)Daniel- Daniel is soooo cute! However, it was like Jay said...."Hi, I'm going back to LA!" in response to how quickly he got ejected. I didn't mind that Daniel was bouncing around and talking his game, although that could've gotten really annoying if he was doing it episode aftr episode....In the first episode, when it came to the judging and displaying of the dress, he kept going on and on about the jacket and what he did for the jacket, but a woman can't wear just a jacket on the town (or she'll get arrested!). It's like, he was so jazzed about what he was doing with the jacket that he forgot to put the same effort into the dress. If he had, then yeah he definitely would've stayed (seeing as how Starr made it, but "just barely").
10)Alexandra- Who? She might be higher on my list if she could get some more airtime and we could get to know her. As for her designs, nothing's really grabbed me so far. I kinda thought her Envy and BR dress looked a little similar...not "the same", but similar. I did like her first outfit.
11)Starr- yeah, she's a little cutie, but it seemed like every bit of her time on the show was spent on the verge of tears. She could not take the criticism well or recognize that her output may not look as good in real life as it does in her head. The first dress, though I did like it, was just a cornucopia of "let's see how much stuff we can pile on here." I absolutely HATE her "cancer dress." An icky green color with veins and tumors on it....Gag! Her BR dress was more costume-y and just not fitting with the theme there. If how much I liked someone was based solely on design, she would easily be last just for the cancer dress alone, but since it's not, she ranks just above Wendy. Really mousy, a bit wimpy, and horrid designs.
12)Wendy- I despise this double life she's leading on the show. Strategist? Or ball of insecurity? As for her designs...I liked the colorful look of the candy bikini and the material she used, but the theme was "innovation" AND "evening wear." Maybe it would've worked for "Carnivale", but it just bombed there. The back of her second dress was sticking out like a scoop or basket or whatever (I'm not a fashion expert so I can't comment on the technical side of things) and I didn't like that. Plus, those threads of material were just dragging on the floor. *shakes head* I did love her Banana R. dress and was proud of how she was able to sell it to the judges. Still, she ranks last for me.